Webinar
VC 301: How VCs Evaluate Deals

Andrew Ervin, Deputy CIO at Alumni Ventures, and Hilary Ncala, EVP of Investor Relations, provided a deep look inside how venture capitalists evaluated a deal — including the scorecards, signals, and screens that turned more than 500 monthly opportunities into a small group of investments worth backing.
See video policy below.

In this session, Andrew and Hilary walked through the disciplined, multi-step process Alumni Ventures used to source, screen, and select investments. They covered the four-category scorecard — Deal Dynamics, Lead Investor, Execution, and Team — used to evaluate each opportunity, the 120-point grading framework behind each decision, and how Alumni Ventures co-invested alongside firms including Andreessen Horowitz, Sequoia, Kleiner Perkins, Khosla Ventures, NEA, and Founders Fund.
The conversation moved through real portfolio examples — from Radiant in advanced microreactors and TRM in blockchain intelligence to Replit in AI-native software creation and RapidSOS in emergency response — to demonstrate how each scorecard category was applied in practice.
Whether you were a current Alumni Ventures investor sharpening your understanding of the team’s decision-making process or an accredited investor evaluating venture capital with a more critical eye, this session provided a clear, framework-driven view of how professional VCs separated signal from noise. Watch the recording to gain a disciplined, repeatable lens for evaluating venture opportunities — and a clearer understanding of what drove outcomes in the asset class.
Key Takeaway
- HomeDiscover the 4-category scorecard — Deal Dynamics, Lead Investor, Execution, and Team — that drives every Alumni Ventures investment decision, illustrated with real portfolio examples
- HomeUnderstand how AV screens 500+ opportunities monthly down to ~20–25 investments at a ~4.5% selection rate, and why the co-investment model with top-tier VCs sits at the core of the strategy
- HomeLearn the diligence frameworks experienced venture investors use — and apply that same disciplined lens to your own evaluation of any venture opportunity
Rated a Top 20 VC Firm by both TIME and CB Insights.
Alumni Ventures is America’s largest venture capital firm for individual investors.
About your presenters
Andy worked at Alumni Ventures from November 2017 to September 2026. Andy was Deputy Chief Investment Officer at Alumni Ventures, where he supports investment operations, analytics, and portfolio management. Previously, Andy held several executive roles at a VC-backed start-up in Boston called MiniLuxe, where he led finance and operations during a period of significant growth. Andy was also a consultant at The Parthenon Group and began his career as an actuary at the Liberty Mutual Group. Andy holds a bachelor’s degree from Penn State University and an MBA from the Tuck School of Business at Dartmouth.
Hilary is a senior leader in financial services with more than 15 years of experience working with investors across market cycles. Since joining Alumni Ventures in 2016, she has been instrumental in building and scaling the firm’s investor relations function, leading high-performing teams and partnering closely with investment, finance, legal, and operations groups to support investors throughout the lifecycle of their venture portfolios with rigor and transparency. Her background in retirement investment planning, including earlier Series 7 and 63 licensure, informs a disciplined perspective on portfolio construction, risk management, liquidity considerations, and long-term capital allocation. Hilary is known for her ability to bring clarity to complex investment topics and for upholding a thoughtful, investor-first experience. She graduated summa cum laude from Fisher College and is currently pursuing her MBA at Boston University.


